{ "export_version": "egoist-public-87-check-v1", "publication_status": "approved", "generated_date": "2026-09-21", "subject": { "id": "yc:32129", "name": "Egoist Machines", "program": "Y Combinator", "cohort": "Summer 2026", "website": "https://ego.ist/", "public_purpose": "consumer_software" }, "scope": { "observation_date": "2026-09-21", "logged_out_public_read_only": true, "no_login_forms_tool_execution_or_security_testing": true, "denominator": "one company-program-cohort row; not a cohort prevalence estimate", "observation_start_date": "2026-09-20", "observation_end_date": "2026-09-21", "date_timezone": "UTC" }, "rubric": { "public_audit_rubric_version": "July 18, 2026", "protocol_version": "1.0-draft (2026-09-19)", "decision_rules_version": "1.1.0", "scoring_schema_version": "1.1.0" }, "status_counts": { "pass": 55, "partial": 22, "fail": 3, "unknown": 0, "na": 3, "not_publicly_verifiable": 4 }, "score": { "final_score": 85.10360654093097, "display_score": 85.1, "coverage_status": "complete", "rank_eligible": true, "unknown_check_ids": [], "not_publicly_verifiable_check_ids": [ "agent.task.confirmation_idempotency", "agent.task.output_errors", "reliability.cache.auth", "reliability.errors.auth_detail" ], "score_note": "This bounded public snapshot is not a field user-experience score, adoption measure, execution result, or target pass rate." }, "signals": { "advertised_discovery": "multiple", "documented_machine_capability": "partial", "observed_tool_registration": "not_measured", "execution": "not_measured", "adoption": "not_measured", "visibility": "not_measured", "signal_note": "Discovery, documented capability, registration, execution, adoption, and visibility are separate fields; no registration or execution is claimed." }, "checks": [ { "check_id": "seo.http.preferred_origin", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "HTTPS and ordinary scheme/host variants resolve to the preferred origin without a loop.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "http.core_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "HTTP/HTTPS and apex/www Egoist variants resolve to the HTTPS apex origin without a loop; sampled homepage bodies share the same hash." }, { "check_id": "seo.http.core_page", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Core public page returns 200 with the intended content type.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "http.core_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The saved homepage returned HTTP 200 with text/html." }, { "check_id": "seo.http.not_found", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "A deliberately nonexistent URL returns a real 404 or 410.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "http.missing_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The deliberate missing path returned HTTP 404." }, { "check_id": "seo.http.machine_errors", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Applicable API or asset misses preserve an appropriate machine-readable error.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "http.machine_error", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-missing.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The advertised Markdown resource family's deliberately missing `/llms-missing.md` returned a real 404 HTML response rather than a successful 200 machine document; status is correct, but the body is generic rather than a typed Markdown error." }, { "check_id": "seo.http.robots_headers", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Public pages do not emit accidental restrictive robots headers.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "http.robots_header_safety", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The sampled pages are indexable and have no restrictive X-Robots-Tag." }, { "check_id": "seo.canonical.page", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Indexable representative pages declare one canonical URL.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "canonical.identity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Homepage, docs, and privacy pages each declare one canonical URL." }, { "check_id": "seo.canonical.target", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Declared canonical resolves to a 200 page without an unnecessary redirect.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "canonical.identity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "All sampled canonical targets equal their saved HTTP 200 final URLs." }, { "check_id": "seo.canonical.duplicate_hosts", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Alternate hosts and duplicate URL variants consolidate consistently.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "canonical.identity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Apex/www and HTTP/HTTPS homepage variants consolidate to the HTTPS apex origin with a stable canonical and body hash." }, { "check_id": "seo.canonical.cross_surface", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "HTML, schema, Open Graph, feeds, sitemaps, Markdown, and manifests agree where present.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2.5, "score_contribution": 2.5, "decision_rule_id": "canonical.identity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://passport.ego.ist/.well-known/openid-configuration", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The sampled HTML canonicals, structured Organization/WebSite URLs, homepage/docs identity, sitemap origin, Markdown resource links, OpenAPI server, and OIDC service documentation all point to the same Egoist/Passport identity without a contradictory host or product target. Explicit machine representations are evaluated under their separate metadata check." }, { "check_id": "seo.canonical.variants", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Query, slash, case, print, pagination, and locale variants do not contradict identity.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "canonical.identity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/?utm_source=public-readiness", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Fresh live representative checks for the homepage query, /docs, /docs/, and /docs?print=1 all returned 200 with clean canonical targets and no robots contradiction." }, { "check_id": "seo.graph.reachable", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Intended representative pages are reachable from an indexable parent.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 3, "score_contribution": 3, "decision_rule_id": "graph.discovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The representative indexable homepage links to Documentation and Privacy Policy, and both linked pages returned HTTP 200 with self-canonicals in the saved public packet." }, { "check_id": "seo.graph.crawlable_links", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Important links are ordinary crawlable anchors in raw or rendered HTML.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "graph.discovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The complete bounded sitemap crawl recorded 124 discovered same-origin links with no query links, while the saved homepage/docs packet shows ordinary anchors for the representative product, docs, privacy, changelog, and agent resources." }, { "check_id": "seo.graph.bounded", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Collections, filters, calendars, and parameters form a bounded graph.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "graph.discovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public llms map is sectioned and bounded, the full 125-location crawl found zero query links, and the saved public route set contains finite sitemap membership rather than an observed filter/calendar parameter expansion." }, { "check_id": "seo.graph.noindex_children", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Noindexed parents are not the only route to important children.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "graph.discovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The complete crawl found five noindex routes, all 404 creator-policy responses with no discovered links; no important child route depended on a noindexed parent. The redundant index/follow token is a separate 404 metadata issue and does not create a crawl-graph defect." }, { "check_id": "seo.graph.orphans", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Sitemap and discovered-canonical comparison identifies orphan pages.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "graph.discovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The full 125-URL sitemap crawl found 86 sitemap-only routes in the bounded internal-link comparison, while the rendered docs/navigation and llms map expose the high-intent developer/agent resources; many sitemap-only routes are public profile/publisher pages, so this is discovery friction rather than a site-wide orphan failure." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.robots", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "robots.txt is valid and references the canonical sitemap where appropriate.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/robots.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "robots.txt allows the public surface and names the canonical sitemap." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.protocol", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Sitemap files are valid and within protocol limits.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The saved sitemap parser observed URLSET and 125 locations." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.url_integrity", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Sitemap URLs resolve to indexable canonicals on the canonical origin.", "status": "fail", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 0, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The complete 125-location sitemap crawl returned five 404 pages, including five creator-policy URLs that remain in the sitemap; two large pages were not fully captured." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.discovered_membership", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Discovered indexable canonicals have appropriate sitemap membership.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 1.0, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The full sitemap is populated and 118 URLs returned 200, but 86 sitemap routes were not found in the bounded internal-link set and five sitemap entries returned 404." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.lastmod", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "lastmod values reflect real public changes when supplied.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/changelog", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The sitemap supplies 2026-08-31 for all sampled entries, while the public changelog contains 2026-09-16 and 2026-09-08 entries. This directly shows stale or overly coarse sitemap freshness for at least the changelog route; no external publication history is required to record the mismatch." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.index_children", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Sitemap indexes and child maps do not fail empty when a route family exists.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The saved Egoist sitemap is a non-empty URLSET with 125 locations; no empty sitemap-index child map was observed." }, { "check_id": "seo.sitemap.purpose_separation", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Search, user retrieval, and training crawler policy are not conflated.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "sitemap.policy", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/robots.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/sitemap.xml", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "robots.txt uses a generic public crawler policy with explicit private/auth/editor disallows and names the sitemap; no contradictory search, user-retrieval, or training policy directive was observed. The absence of a separate training policy is retained as context, not treated as conflation." }, { "check_id": "seo.render.initial_html", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Primary meaning, title, headings, facts, and important links are in initial HTML or reliably rendered.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.25, "score_contribution": 1.25, "decision_rule_id": "render.initial", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Initial HTML includes the AI Passport title, identity, capabilities, and privacy/docs text." }, { "check_id": "seo.render.hydration_parity", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Hydration does not remove or materially contradict initial content.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "render.initial", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "Rendered views retain the AI Passport title and primary identity text from raw HTML." }, { "check_id": "seo.render.text_access", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Important text is available as text rather than only image, canvas, or inaccessible widget content.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "render.initial", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "The rendered desktop/mobile captures expose product and developer documentation as text." }, { "check_id": "seo.render.interstitials", "dimension": "seo", "criterion": "Consent banners and interstitials do not make the public page unavailable.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.75, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "render.initial", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "The mobile/public FAQ pass exposed no consent or blocking interstitial; the page remained readable and FAQ controls were usable without authentication." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.entity", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Organization, product/service name, category, and identity are explicit.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public title and H1 identify Egoist AI Passport." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.capabilities", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Capabilities and explicit exclusions are understandable from public sources.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Homepage and docs state portable memory/context, AI application integrations, sign-in, agents, and managed partner integrations." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.availability", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Platforms, regions, languages, availability, compatibility, or service area are stated as applicable.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The docs name iPhone/iPad sign-in, agents, and integration paths." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.commercial_terms", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Price, currency, interval, limits, trial, cancellation, refund, overage, or quote policy is clear when applicable.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 1.0, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The homepage states free for life, but no limits, quota, cancellation, or paid upgrade terms are captured." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.integration_trust", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Integration, support, security, privacy, status, and escalation facts are available when applicable.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/trust", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/changelog", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public Trust and Support pages provide security/privacy boundaries, revocation/export/deletion guidance, named support, response timing, and common account questions, with linked privacy/docs/contact paths." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.freshness", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Freshness or effective state is visible when facts can change the answer.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The privacy policy exposes an effective date, while product capability freshness is not dated." }, { "check_id": "aeo.truth.cross_surface", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Public representations and action destinations agree on material facts.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "truth.public_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://passport.ego.ist/.well-known/openid-configuration", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "Homepage, llms map, install guide, OpenAPI, and OIDC discovery consistently identify AI Passport and its developer/agent integration purpose, while commercial/current terms remain incomplete across surfaces." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.type_match", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Schema type matches the actual business/page purpose.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Structured types include SoftwareApplication, Offer, Organization, and WebSite for an AI software product." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.visible_parity", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Structured facts are visible and agree with the page.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Freshly captured JSON-LD contains Organization, WebSite, SoftwareApplication, and Offer facts that agree with the visible AI Passport identity, web/product category, portable-context description, free-for-life/$0 offer, and publisher." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.stable_ids", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Stable entity/product/location/author identifiers are used consistently where relevant.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The homepage/docs structured payloads identify the Egoist organization and website consistently, but the saved payload does not establish stable IDs for every product/partner entity." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.current_facts", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Prices, availability, ratings, dates, and authors are current rather than invented or stale.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The homepage structured payload includes SoftwareApplication/Offer data aligned with free-for-life copy, while the public docs/OpenAPI expose current beta version and integration facts outside schema." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.faq_howto", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "FAQ or HowTo data corresponds to visible content when present.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The homepage visibly exposes FAQ controls, but no FAQ/HowTo structured type was captured in the homepage/docs payloads." }, { "check_id": "aeo.schema.syntax", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Applicable structured data parses successfully.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "schema.semantic_parity", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The saved structured-data parser found typed JSON-LD with zero parse errors." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.alternate_advertised", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Applicable Markdown or other reference representation is advertised through a valid alternate/link.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.25, "score_contribution": 1.25, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Developer docs advertise /llms.txt and /llms-install.md alternates." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.clean_markdown", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Applicable direct Markdown or content-negotiated response is clean and correctly typed.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.25, "score_contribution": 1.25, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.mdx/agents", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The advertised Markdown resources returned readable substantive bodies with their intended text/plain or text/markdown content types; canonical/update metadata and fact parity are evaluated by separate checks." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.negotiation_cache", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Content negotiation and cache behavior use Vary and safe cache directives.", "status": "na", "applicability": "not_applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "not_applicable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public machine representations use distinct explicit URLs such as /llms-install.md and /partner-openapi.json; no HTML/Markdown content negotiation endpoint was exposed in the saved public contract.", "applicability_reason": "The observed public machine contract uses explicit representation URLs and does not advertise negotiated HTML/Markdown variants; Vary: Accept is not applicable without content negotiation." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.fact_parity", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Machine representation matches canonical HTML facts and links back to it.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.25, "score_contribution": 1.25, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Live sampled llms, install, agent-install, and OpenAPI representations agree with the homepage/docs identity and capabilities. The $1,000/month startup offer is explicitly segmented as AI Passport for Startups rather than contradicting the personal free-for-life product." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.metadata", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Applicable Markdown includes canonical, locale, version, or update metadata.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The OpenAPI document exposes version 1.0.0-beta and the Markdown maps identify canonical public resource paths, but the Markdown responses lack explicit canonical/update metadata." }, { "check_id": "aeo.machine.missing_error", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Missing machine representation returns a useful error rather than HTML disguised as Markdown.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": 0.125, "decision_rule_id": "machine.reference_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-missing.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "A deliberately missing advertised-style Markdown path returned HTTP 404 with text/html rather than a successful Markdown body; the response is a real missing page but does not provide a machine-specific Markdown error representation." }, { "check_id": "aeo.discovery.map", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "An applicable discovery map points to canonical high-intent resources.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "discovery.map_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The docs page points to bounded developer/agent resources and Markdown alternates." }, { "check_id": "aeo.discovery.valid_links", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "Discovery-map links resolve and retain correct hosts and formats.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "discovery.map_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.mdx/agents", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-agent-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The advertised llms map's sampled first-party agent/install/full-corpus and Partner OpenAPI links resolved with their expected public text/JSON formats; the external GitHub link is outside this representative first-party scope." }, { "check_id": "aeo.discovery.bounded", "dimension": "aeo", "criterion": "The discovery map is bounded and useful rather than a stale duplicate dump.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "discovery.map_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public llms map is sectioned into agent resources, product, docs, and a full corpus link rather than an unbounded duplicate dump." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.semantics_names", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Interactive elements use valid semantics and descriptive programmatic names.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 2, "score_contribution": 2, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "accessibility_tree" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "screenshot" } ], "observation": "The reviewed AX tree exposes 33 interactive nodes with nonempty programmatic names, including native links, buttons, and the two handle textboxes; the representative keyboard sequence reaches those public controls." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.inputs_errors", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Inputs have labels, constraints, autocomplete, and accessible errors where applicable.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "accessibility_tree" } ], "observation": "The live public handle input has a visible placeholder, autocomplete=username, and maxLength=20, while required/pattern/aria-error metadata is absent and no validation transition was entered. The private claim action was not clicked." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.keyboard_focus", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Keyboard order, visible focus, dialog focus, and route focus are usable.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "screenshot" } ], "observation": "The bounded Tab and reverse-Tab traversal reaches the public homepage controls with named visible focus and no observed trap; the page has no public navigation-menu state requiring a separate menu traversal." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.structure", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Headings and landmarks make the page navigable.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "accessibility_tree" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "accessibility_tree" } ], "observation": "The representative homepage has a named overview region, main landmark, labeled content regions, and meaningful H1/H2/H3 headings covering product identity, workflow, content sections, and FAQ. The main landmark does not require an accessible label; the repeated marketing H1 nodes are meaningful responsive content and are not treated as an automatic hierarc…" }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.mobile_text", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Critical controls remain usable on mobile and increased text size.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "A controlled local 200% per-element text stress doubled computed font sizes for a visible hero heading, body paragraph, LOGIN link, handle input, and FAQ button. Critical controls remained within the 390px viewport with no overlap or horizontal clipping in the captured screenshot." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.dynamic_state", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Dynamic state changes are announced or otherwise observable where needed.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Repeated public FAQ interactions changed expanded state, exposed the answer, and returned to closed state without page errors; the state is observable through the control and rendered answer." }, { "check_id": "agent.a11y.overlays", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Banners, widgets, dialogs, and overlays do not obscure or trap the core path.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.5, "score_contribution": 1.5, "decision_rule_id": "a11y.core_path", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Across ten public desktop/mobile runs, no consent banner, chat widget, modal, or blocking overlay appeared; FAQ expansion remained within the page and the public core controls stayed available." }, { "check_id": "agent.stability.space", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Images, embeds, ads, and asynchronous sections reserve space.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "stability.layout", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Across the representative homepage at desktop and mobile, all 49 images were complete with nonzero intrinsic and rendered dimensions, and repeated load/FAQ runs recorded no layout-shift entries without recent user input." }, { "check_id": "agent.stability.movement", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Controls do not move materially between observation and interaction.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "stability.layout", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Login and handle-input document coordinates remain unchanged across three FAQ open/close repeats at desktop and mobile. The FAQ accordion's own expansion and focus scroll are expected user-triggered reflow, not autonomous movement of unrelated targets." }, { "check_id": "agent.stability.responsive", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Responsive layout keeps critical actions reachable without obstruction or overflow.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "stability.layout", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "The saved desktop/mobile rendered captures keep the sampled primary/login, FAQ, handle-input, and claim controls within their 1280px and 390px viewports without horizontal overflow or an observed obstruction. Increased text and interaction semantics are assessed separately." }, { "check_id": "agent.stability.loading_motion", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Loading/disabled states are clear and motion respects reduced-motion preferences.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "stability.layout", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "The reduced-motion capture reports no animations while the public FAQ remains operable; the representative homepage exposes no loading/disabled control state during the audited path." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.action_scope", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable public action explains read/write/purchase/message scope and commit boundary.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-agent-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/directed-disclosure", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/partners", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public install, agent, directed-disclosure, and partner docs state that the task reads owner-approved context or sends owner-approved messages, identify the approval/commit boundary, and distinguish hosted, personal-agent, and partner paths before any commit." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.inputs_auth", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable action exposes required inputs, authentication, and authorization constraints.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "The public sign-in contract states client metadata document fields, redirect URI host constraints, token endpoint auth method, state, PKCE S256, issuer, nonce, scopes, memory resource, and partnerKey security; visible login/handle controls match the documented public action without requiring login during this audit." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.cost_limits", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable action explains price, quota, rate limit, timeout, and availability.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public map states startup pricing, and OpenAPI/docs expose rate-limited error classes and scoped operations, but complete quota/timeout terms are not public." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.output_errors", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable action explains expected success, recoverable errors, and terminal failures.", "status": "not_publicly_verifiable", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "not_publicly_verifiable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "Egoist's public action is visible, but its post-submit errors/confirmation and idempotency behavior cross the safe read-only audit boundary.", "public_boundary_reason": "Requires owner documentation or a safe sandbox/private action receipt; this public audit stopped before submission, authentication, booking, or write execution." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.confirmation_idempotency", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable write action has confirmation, idempotency, and safe stop behavior.", "status": "not_publicly_verifiable", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "not_publicly_verifiable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "Egoist's public action is visible, but its post-submit errors/confirmation and idempotency behavior cross the safe read-only audit boundary.", "public_boundary_reason": "Requires owner documentation or a safe sandbox/private action receipt; this public audit stopped before submission, authentication, booking, or write execution." }, { "check_id": "agent.task.escalation", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable action explains human escalation or support.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "task.public_boundary", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/support", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The public Support page names [contact omitted] and a usual two-business-day response, while Trust/docs/going-live provide recovery, owner-approval, and contact paths for the public integration task." }, { "check_id": "agent.capabilities.api_contract", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable public API has an OpenAPI or equivalent contract.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1.25, "score_contribution": 1.25, "decision_rule_id": "capability.contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Egoist publishes a non-empty OpenAPI 3.1 partner contract with authenticated operations, request schemas, response schemas, versions, and explicit error codes/statuses." }, { "check_id": "agent.capabilities.oauth_discovery", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable authenticated integration exposes OAuth/resource discovery and scopes.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "capability.contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://passport.ego.ist/.well-known/openid-configuration", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The advertised sign-in guide points to a public OIDC discovery document that returns issuer, authorization/token endpoints, JWKS, PKCE S256, device authorization, scopes, and CIMD support." }, { "check_id": "agent.capabilities.skill", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable hosted Agent Skill is discoverable and useful.", "status": "na", "applicability": "not_applicable", "points": 0.75, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "capability.contract", "evidence_class": "not_applicable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Egoist's advertised public machine surfaces are OIDC, OpenAPI, Markdown, and MCP/agent resources; no hosted Agent Skill surface is advertised in the public map or docs.", "applicability_reason": "A hosted Agent Skill does not fit the observed public integration contract; the public agent path is documented through OIDC/OpenAPI/MCP resources instead." }, { "check_id": "agent.capabilities.mcp_webmcp", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable MCP/WebMCP exposes a real product task; registration remains separately observed.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "capability.contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public llms map and install guide advertise hosted MCP assistants, messaging tools, and the Passport MCP resource; no authenticated MCP metadata or invocation was attempted." }, { "check_id": "agent.capabilities.operational_metadata", "dimension": "agent", "criterion": "Applicable capability states versions, scopes, limits, errors, and confirmation boundaries.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "capability.contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://passport.ego.ist/.well-known/openid-configuration", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "public_document" } ], "observation": "The OpenAPI and OIDC documents expose versions, security schemes, scopes, endpoint classes, and error codes, but do not fully state all operational limits and confirmation boundaries." }, { "check_id": "reliability.performance.ttfb", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Representative mobile/desktop TTFB is measured.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "performance.ttfb", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Saved Lighthouse lab profiles stayed separate (desktop median=191.0 p90=192.0 ms (pass); mobile median=631.0 p90=633.6 ms (pass)); conservative verdict=pass.", "measurements": [ { "metric": "ttfb", "value": 191.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].timeToFirstByte; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "ttfb", "value": 192.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].timeToFirstByte; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "ttfb", "value": 631.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].timeToFirstByte; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "ttfb", "value": 633.6, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].timeToFirstByte; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." } ] }, { "check_id": "reliability.performance.lcp", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Representative mobile/desktop LCP is measured.", "status": "fail", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0, "decision_rule_id": "performance.lcp", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Saved Lighthouse lab profiles stayed separate (desktop median=1603.0 p90=1842.2 ms (pass); mobile median=6990.0 p90=7093.0 ms (fail)); conservative verdict=fail.", "measurements": [ { "metric": "lcp", "value": 1603.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].largestContentfulPaint; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "lcp", "value": 1842.2, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].largestContentfulPaint; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "lcp", "value": 6990.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].largestContentfulPaint; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "lcp", "value": 7093.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].largestContentfulPaint; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." } ] }, { "check_id": "reliability.performance.cls", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Representative mobile/desktop CLS is measured.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 1, "decision_rule_id": "performance.cls", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Saved Lighthouse lab profiles stayed separate (desktop median=0.0001153172096631206 p90=0.0002700878962683872 ratio (pass); mobile median=0.0 p90=0.001808985884794211 ratio (pass)); conservative verdict=pass.", "measurements": [ { "metric": "cls", "value": 0.0001153172096631206, "unit": "ratio", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].cumulativeLayoutShift; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "cls", "value": 0.0002700878962683872, "unit": "ratio", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=desktop; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].cumulativeLayoutShift; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "cls", "value": 0.0, "unit": "ratio", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].cumulativeLayoutShift; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." }, { "metric": "cls", "value": 0.001808985884794211, "unit": "ratio", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "p90", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "viewport=mobile; Lighthouse 13.5.0; Chrome 153; five repeats per desktop/mobile viewport; simulated throttling; logged out; raw metric locator=audits.metrics.details.items[0].cumulativeLayoutShift; raw reports retained in the Lighthouse receipt." } ] }, { "check_id": "reliability.performance.transfer_interaction", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Transfer size, blocking resources, image weight, and interaction responsiveness are measured.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 1, "score_contribution": 0.5, "decision_rule_id": "performance.transfer_interaction", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-21", "source_kind": "performance_trace" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "performance_trace" } ], "observation": "Trusted FAQ clicks produced browser Event Timing entries with 32–40ms durations after warmup; three repeats ran at each viewport with no page errors. Transfer and blocking observations remain bounded to the saved resource/interaction packet, so no field INP claim is made.", "measurements": [ { "metric": "transfer_bytes", "value": 1413189, "unit": "bytes", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=desktop; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim." }, { "metric": "request_count", "value": 57, "unit": "count", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=desktop; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim." }, { "metric": "blocking_resource_count", "value": 3, "unit": "count", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=desktop; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim.; blocking CSS resource count." }, { "metric": "other", "value": 394, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=desktop; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim.; longest dependency-chain duration, not a long-task or field metric." }, { "metric": "other", "value": 32.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 3, "conditions": "Controlled FAQ Event Timing entries; viewport=desktop; three repeats; values 32–40ms; interaction timing only, not field INP." }, { "metric": "transfer_bytes", "value": 1342136, "unit": "bytes", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=mobile; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim." }, { "metric": "request_count", "value": 50, "unit": "count", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=mobile; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim." }, { "metric": "blocking_resource_count", "value": 3, "unit": "count", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=mobile; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim.; blocking CSS resource count." }, { "metric": "other", "value": 286, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 5, "conditions": "Controlled Lighthouse lab homepage run; viewport=mobile; Chrome 153; five repeats; simulated throttling; logged out; transfer/resource diagnostics only; no field claim.; longest dependency-chain duration, not a long-task or field metric." }, { "metric": "other", "value": 32.0, "unit": "ms", "source": "lab", "aggregation": "median", "sample_count": 3, "conditions": "Controlled FAQ Event Timing entries; viewport=mobile; three repeats; values 32–40ms; interaction timing only, not field INP." } ] }, { "check_id": "reliability.cache.directives", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "HTML, Markdown, API, and error responses use appropriate cache directives.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.75, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "cache.representation", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Saved homepage/docs/privacy responses use public max-age=0, must-revalidate." }, { "check_id": "reliability.cache.vary", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Content-negotiated responses use Vary correctly.", "status": "na", "applicability": "not_applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "cache.representation", "evidence_class": "not_applicable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public Markdown and OpenAPI representations are separate explicit URLs, and the saved packet exposes no alternate representation selected by Accept negotiation.", "applicability_reason": "This cache check applies to content-negotiated responses; the observed contract has distinct explicit .md and .json URLs and no Accept-based alternate." }, { "check_id": "reliability.cache.auth", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Personalized/authenticated responses are not publicly cacheable.", "status": "not_publicly_verifiable", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "cache.representation", "evidence_class": "not_publicly_verifiable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "Egoist exposes or implies an authenticated/private boundary, but the logged-out public packet cannot verify reliability.cache.auth.", "public_boundary_reason": "Requires authenticated or owner-provided cache/error evidence; no login, invalid [private detail omitted]." }, { "check_id": "reliability.cache.challenge_content_type", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "A CDN or challenge does not masquerade as a successful Markdown/API response.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "cache.representation", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms.txt", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-missing.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Sampled Egoist Markdown, OpenAPI JSON, HTML docs, and missing Markdown responses preserve ordinary content types/statuses; no challenge body masqueraded as successful machine content." }, { "check_id": "reliability.freshness.effective_state", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Dates and effective states are explicit or omitted rather than fabricated.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "freshness.provenance", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/changelog", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "Egoist publishes a changelog and a beta OpenAPI version, while product capability and free-for-life claims are not uniformly dated." }, { "check_id": "reliability.freshness.commercial_compatibility", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Pricing, availability, compatibility, policy, and status facts expose current state.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.75, "score_contribution": 0.375, "decision_rule_id": "freshness.provenance", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public llms map states AI Passport for Startups pricing (three months free, six for YC companies, then $1,000/month flat) and the homepage states free for life for the personal product; limits/cancellation/eligibility details are not fully unified." }, { "check_id": "reliability.freshness.provenance", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Research, editorial, regulated, or high-stakes claims expose appropriate source/provenance.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "freshness.provenance", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/privacy-policy", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The privacy policy has an effective date and named operator; product capability sources are not separately versioned." }, { "check_id": "reliability.freshness.deprecated_replacement", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Deprecated products/endpoints identify replacement or end date when applicable.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": 0.125, "decision_rule_id": "freshness.provenance", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/llms-install.md", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" }, { "url": "https://ego.ist/docs/changelog", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public install guide states that DCR remains deprecated and directs current clients toward host-consistent metadata-document/CIMD admission; the replacement/end-state is publicly described but not a full migration contract." }, { "check_id": "reliability.errors.http_status", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Public errors preserve correct HTTP status.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.75, "score_contribution": 0.75, "decision_rule_id": "http.missing_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The exact deliberate missing URL returned HTTP 404; no site-wide inference is made." }, { "check_id": "reliability.errors.next_step", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Error text explains what failed and a safe next step.", "status": "fail", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.5, "score_contribution": 0.0, "decision_rule_id": "errors.recovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The saved 404 body states that the page could not be found but does not expose a safe next step." }, { "check_id": "reliability.errors.404_noindex", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "A conversion-oriented 404 remains a real noindexed 404.", "status": "pass", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": 0.25, "decision_rule_id": "http.missing_contract", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/mudpie-readiness-missing-a7e59443b5d6c5fa", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The exact 404 carries noindex; the additional index, follow token is redundant source markup, but the restrictive noindex rule remains effective." }, { "check_id": "reliability.errors.auth_detail", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Applicable auth errors distinguish missing, invalid, expired, and insufficient scope safely.", "status": "not_publicly_verifiable", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": null, "decision_rule_id": "errors.recovery", "evidence_class": "not_publicly_verifiable", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "rendered_dom" } ], "observation": "Egoist exposes or implies an authenticated/private boundary, but the logged-out public packet cannot verify reliability.errors.auth_detail.", "public_boundary_reason": "Requires authenticated or owner-provided cache/error evidence; no login, invalid [private detail omitted]." }, { "check_id": "reliability.errors.rate_limit_retry", "dimension": "reliability", "criterion": "Applicable rate limits and temporary failures communicate retry behavior.", "status": "partial", "applicability": "applicable", "points": 0.25, "score_contribution": 0.125, "decision_rule_id": "errors.recovery", "evidence_class": "observed", "evidence": [ { "url": "https://ego.ist/partner-openapi.json", "observed_date": "2026-09-20", "source_kind": "raw_http" } ], "observation": "The public OpenAPI contract enumerates rate_limited errors and 429 responses for partner operations, but it does not publish a retry interval or backoff policy." } ], "limitations": [ "Performance values are controlled lab observations; they are not field Core Web Vitals or user-impact claims.", "The 200% text result is a local computed-style stress test, not native browser text zoom or universal route certification.", "The FAQ movement pass excludes expected user-triggered accordion reflow and focus scrolling.", "N/A applies only to explicit non-applicability; NPV rows are visible owner/private exclusions and are not failures.", "No login, form submission, account creation, tool invocation, rate-limit bypass, or security test was performed." ] }